In this article, we’re going to look at the question “Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS”?
Before we get started, it’s important to understand that both manufacturers are located in Taiwan and create NAS (network attached storage) devices. They also create other devices, but we’re focusing on NAS devices in this article.
Everything discussed in this “Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS” article will be written from a general standpoint, as both manufacturers create various different NAS devices that each have strengths/weaknesses.
1. Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS?
From a general perspective, QNAP has released more powerful and more capable NAS devices then Synology has historically.
Looking at our article where we compare the Synology DS720+ and the QNAP TS-253D, the Synology and QNAP have the same processor, but the QNAP device comes with more memory and a better network interface card (NIC).
This is true of the 4-bay NAS devices as well (and most other NAS devices), as the Synology DS920+ and QNAP TS453-D both come with the same processor, but the QNAP device comes with more memory and a 2.5Gb NIC as opposed to the 1Gb NIC the Synology offers.
Another difference is that almost all QNAP devices offer PCI-E expansion slots. Synology does offer PCI-E expansion slots on their DS1621+ and up model line, but the DS220+, DS720+, DS420+, DS920+ and DS1520+ do not have this capability. This allows the QNAP models to run 5Gb or 10Gb networking if desired – something these Synology models can’t.
The final difference is that some Synology models come with M.2 2280 NVME SSD cache slots (excluding the drives) that the QNAP counterparts don’t have. This can be added on a QNAP device by utilizing the PCI-E expansion slot, but then you can’t upgrade the networking to 5Gb or 10Gb if desired.
Finally, Synology devices are normally slightly more expensive, but it’s not significant enough to sway you one way or another.
2. DSM vs. QTS – Operating System Comparison
By default, Synology devices run DSM 7 and QNAP devices run QTS 5 operating systems. For any Synology model you purchase, you’ll be running DSM 7. However, certain QNAP devices run the QuTS Hero operating system (differences covered below). With that said, most consumer NAS devices run the QTS 5 operating system.
Both, DSM 7 and QTS 5 offer similar functionality and different applications that you can run on your NAS. Synology DSM 7 uses the Package Center to install applications and QNAP’s QTS uses the App Center. Overall, they both function the same and simply allow you to download applications.
2.1 Synology OS: DiskStation Manager 7 (DSM 7)
Synology DSM 7 is a Linux-based operating system that has a web management GUI. What this means is that you can easily access it through any device on your local network that has a web browser.
DSM 7 is known for being incredibly user-friendly and has an awesome community behind it.
2.2 QNAP OS: QTS 5
Similar to DSM 7, QTS 5 is a Linux-based operating system that has a web management GUI. It’s incredibly similar to DSM 7 from a functionality standpoint, but is less user-friendly. That’s not to say that QTS 5 is bad (because it’s not), it’s just a little more difficult to navigate through and understand – especially if you’re a beginner.
QTS 5 uses QNAP’s App Center and similar to Synology, there are tons of different applications you can utilize. One key difference that users might be happy with is that out-of-the-box, the Linux kernel that QNAP utilizes supports the WireGuard VPN protocol.
As of right now, Synology does not support WireGuard and there have been no reports of it coming anytime soon. This is said to highlight that while both operating systems are similar, there are major differences when it comes to the packages.
2.3 DSM and QTS Live Demo’s – Synology vs. QNAP
Before you purchase either, it is in your best interest test-drive both as Synology and QNAP both offer online demos that you can try. These are fully functional demo devices, meaning that you can navigate the UI, download packages, view security settings and more.
It is in your best interest to try both of these before you purchase a NAS.
2.3.1 Synology DSM 7 Live Demo
1. Navigate to the Synology DSM demo site and select Try DSM 7.1.
2. After a few seconds, you should be able to Launch an instance of DSM 7.1 and you’ll have 30 minutes to use the operating system.
3. When you are done testing out the system, be sure to test QNAP’s QTS operating system below. This will give you a good idea of both operating systems so you can decide on an OS with confidence!
2.3.2 QNAP QTS 5 Live Demo
1. Navigate to the QNAP QTS demo site and select Try it Now.
NOTE: The demo will show as QuTScloud, but this is the same QTS OS that will run on a QNAP device. QuTScloud is a new offering from QNAP that allows you to self-host their software on your own hardware.
2. You will be given an account username and password. Remember these credentials and press Start.
3. The QTS operating system will now load, and you can try it out!
2.4 DSM vs. QTS
When looking at DSM vs. QTS and using it, DSM is the clear winner to me. DSM is incredibly easy to use, has a ton of possibilities as far as usage goes, and is rock solid. There’s nothing more that you want or need in a NAS.
3. RAID – Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS?
NAS devices are utilized mostly for their network attached storage and RAID capabilities. Synology and QNAP offer extremely similar functionality for RAID, with both supporting RAID 0, 1, 5, 6 and 10. There are other RAID types as well for QNAP (RAID 50, 60 and Triple Parity), but most consumers will use one of the RAID types mentioned above.
Synology does have SHR (Synology Hybrid RAID) as well, which is awesome for home users. Mainly because SHR offers a ton of flexibility to users and allows them to use different sized hard drives (where traditional RAID setups require the same sized hard drives).
I suggest that you check out Synology’s RAID Calculator or QNAP’s RAID Calculator to see the different types of RAID options you can use and determine which is best for you. This will also give you a good idea of how Synology SHR works.
3.1 File System Types – Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS?
Both, Synology and QNAP give users the option of using Ext4. However, Synology offers Btrfs as well, which is incredibly important as it can fix corruption from bit-rot automatically. Please keep in mind that not all Synology devices support Btrfs, so you should purchase one that does, but this is not an option with QNAP.
QNAP does support ZFS on their QuTS Hero operating system, but most consumers won’t be purchasing devices that use QuTS Hero. Synology does not support ZFS either, but Btrfs is still superior to Ext4 from a data protection standpoint.
3.2 Hard Drive Support
Recently, it has been speculated that Synology will begin supporting specific hard drives and unsupported hard drives will receive a warning. Currently, this isn’t an issue for consumer devices, but it’s certainly something to keep an eye on.
For now, both Synology and QNAP allow you to utilize any hard drive that you’d like. It is important to remember that you should always purchase a NAS hard drive, so please check out our guide on the best NAS hard drives to purchase to ensure you get one that will last.
4. Applications – Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS?
- By default, DSM and QTS are extremely similar, though their packages differ greatly. I will be focusing on data and backups, as NAS devices are mainly used as…NAS’s.
Synology and QNAP allow you to create shared folders inside of their Control Panel. They both also utilize a program called File Station to view the files in the operating system. However, you’ll mostly be accessing your files using something like SMB.
Shared Folder’s store the files that you’ll be accessing on your NAS.
Synology Shared Folder Creation
QNAP Shared Folder Creation
File Station is used for Synology and QNAP to view your files inside the DSM or QTS OS.
Synology File Station
QNAP File Station
4.2 NAS Backups – Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS?
Synology and QNAP both have options that you can use to back up your NAS. To ensure that you follow the 3-2-1 backup strategy, it’s important to be able to back up the data on your NAS to a separate location.
Synology utilizes a tool called Hyper Backup and QNAP utilizes a tool called Hybrid Backup Sync 3. Overall, I’ve found Hyper Backup to be significantly easier to use, but they both do a good job of backing up the data on your NAS.
Synology Hyper Backup
QNAP Hybrid Backup Sync 3
There are tons of other applications that you can run on these devices, but focusing on their core usage, they both function well as a NAS and allow you to easily back up your data off-site.
5. Security – Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS?
Security is something that has many, many layers and the security needed will depend on many factors, including exactly what you’re looking to do with your NAS.
For example, if you intend on not exposing your NAS outside of your local network (which you shouldn’t – use a VPN), the overall security of the device is less of an importance than people who intend on exposing it.
That’s not to say that security isn’t important (because it is). It’s just to highlight that the security practices you’re looking for will be different depending on what you’re trying to accomplish.
4.1 So…which is more secure? Synology or QNAP
After discussing why it’s not a good idea to expose your NAS, if you must, Synology wins here…fairly easily.
That’s not to say that Synology devices haven’t, but from an overall security perspective, Synology is far superior.
There’s an extremely simple rule that you should follow – don’t expose your NAS outside of your local network. If you own a QNAP device, absolutely do not expose your QNAP NAS outside of your local network.
5. Hard Drive Expansion – Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS?
When you purchase a NAS device, they come with a set number of drive-bays that can be used. I would speculate that most users don’t expand their devices outside of the total number of bays that they purchased, but the important part is that they can be expanded if desired…with a Synology.
If you’d like to expand a Synology NAS, you can use a DX517. However, you must purchase a NAS that can be expanded. Check out our article on the best Synology NAS devices to buy to ensure that you purchase one that supports expansion.
QNAP devices can be expanded as well, but only in the enterprise space. Consumer NAS devices cannot be expanded.
6. Support – Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS?
Up to this point, we’ve discussed various things that you can use your NAS device for. However, if there isn’t an active community behind them, you’ll have a harder time implementing features and troubleshooting issues.
Synology and QNAP both offer support that you can contact, however, sometimes it’s easiest to post on a forum or social media platform like Reddit to get answers to the questions you have.
In this area, Synology is superior…by a long shot. The community behind Synology is incredible and you’ll find tons of articles and guides on how to do different things online.
If you don’t believe me, check out the Google search volume below for Synology NAS, QNAP NAS, TrueNAS and Unraid. All of these are NAS devices/OS’s, and QNAP’s is the lowest…by a longshot.
You can also compare their reddit communities, where Synology currently has 101,000+ users and QNAP only has a little more than 19,000. This might not sound like a big deal, but if you need support or just want to learn how to do something, it’ll be significantly easier with a Synology NAS.
7. VERDICT – Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS?
After comparing almost everything in terms of Synology vs. QNAP, we come to a very clear winner. The main category that QNAP seems to always win is hardware, as they tend to put together more powerful devices.
However, from a software perspective, Synology is the clear winner. Not only is the software generally more secure, but there’s better support, their consumer devices support Btrfs, they can be expanded if needed, and their operating system is significantly easier to use.
That’s not to say that QNAP devices are bad, and I’m sure that there are many users that are, or would be very happy with them, but in a heads-up Synology vs. QNAP debate, Synology is the clear winner.
Make sure you check out our article on the best Synology NAS devices to purchase, because you want to make sure that you purchase a device that supports Btrfs! This is very important for data protection!
If you do purchase a Synology NAS, check out our ultimate guide on how to set it up!
8. Conclusion – Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS?
While it’s been made clear that I prefer Synology devices when comparing “iShould I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS”, you must compare both devices. That’s the main reason I highly suggest checking out and testing both operating systems. While I find DSM easier to use, it’s in your best interest to try it out yourself.
Thanks for checking out the article. If you have any questions on “Should I Buy a Synology or QNAP NAS”, please leave them in the comments!